Exploring mentors’ interpretation of terminology and levels of competence when assessing nursing students: an integrative review

Journal article


Almalkawi, I, Jester, R and Terry, LM (2018). Exploring mentors’ interpretation of terminology and levels of competence when assessing nursing students: an integrative review. Nurse Education Today. 69, pp. 95-103.
AuthorsAlmalkawi, I, Jester, R and Terry, LM
Abstract

Objectives: The purpose of this integrative review is to evaluate the empirical and theoretical literature on the challenges mentors face in interpreting and assessing levels of competence of student nurses in clinical practice. Design: An integrative review of the literature. Data sources: An extensive and systematic literature search was conducted covering the period 1986-September 2016 across twelve databases covering health and education related publications. Grey literature was searched from wide relevant sources. Review methods: Sources were eligible for review when they referred to mentor’s interpretation or assessment of student nurses’ level of competence in practice settings. Methodological rigor of the included studies was evaluated with the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool. Results: After screening 1951records by titles, abstracts and full text, 8 were selected for review. The methodological quality of the studies was moderate. The studies reported: • Difficulties in the language used to describe competencies. • The challenge of distinguishing between different levels of competence. • Lack of clear and constructive feedback to students. Accurate and fair assessment of students is impeded by a lack of transparent and explicit criteria. Conclusions: There is a need to establish a transparent and common language to distinguish between and facilitate interpretation of different levels of competence. Well-designed rubrics might offer the solution to the challenges faced in practice-based assessment and necessitates further research into their use.

KeywordsIntegrative review; students; mentors; Practice-based assessment; competence; interpretation; rubric; feedback; 1110 Nursing; Nursing
Year2018
JournalNurse Education Today
Journal citation69, pp. 95-103
PublisherElsevier
ISSN0260-6917
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1016/j.nedt.2018.07.003
Web address (URL)https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0260691718302922?via%3Dihub
Publication dates
Print12 Aug 2018
Publication process dates
Deposited18 Jul 2018
Accepted10 Jul 2018
Accepted author manuscript
License
CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
File Access Level
Open
Permalink -

https://openresearch.lsbu.ac.uk/item/869wq

Download files

Accepted author manuscript
The final accepted draft NET Almalkawi paper.docx
License: CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
File access level: Open

  • 30
    total views
  • 29
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Factors influencing nurses’ engagement with continuing professional development activities: A systematic review
Walter, J and Terry, L (2020). Factors influencing nurses’ engagement with continuing professional development activities: A systematic review. British Journal of Nursing.
Understanding and using personality type in healthcare communication
Terry, L. (2020). Understanding and using personality type in healthcare communication. Nursing Standard. 35 (6).
Human Rights in Nursing Practice
Terry, L. and Newham, R. (2020). Human Rights in Nursing Practice. Nursing Standard: promoting excellence in nursing care.
Outrage and the emotional labour associated with environmental activism among nurses
Terry, L. and Bowman, K. (2019). Outrage and the emotional labour associated with environmental activism among nurses. Journal of Advanced Nursing.
Using a scoring rubric to make practice-based assessment of pre-registration nursing students fit for purpose: A mixed methods study
Almalkawi, I. (2019). Using a scoring rubric to make practice-based assessment of pre-registration nursing students fit for purpose: A mixed methods study. PhD Thesis London South Bank University School of Health and Social Care
A phenomenological study of becoming and being an environmentally 'woke' nurse
Terry, L, Bowman, K and West, R (2019). A phenomenological study of becoming and being an environmentally 'woke' nurse. Nursing Outlook.
Patients’ and healthcare professionals’ experiences and perceptions of physiotherapy services in the emergency department: A qualitative systematic review
Barrett, R and Terry, L (2018). Patients’ and healthcare professionals’ experiences and perceptions of physiotherapy services in the emergency department: A qualitative systematic review. International Journal of Emergency Medicine. 11 (1).
Supporting people with learning disabilities to make and maintain intimate relationships
Bates, C, Terry, LM and Popple, K (2017). Supporting people with learning disabilities to make and maintain intimate relationships. Tizard Learning Disability Review. 22 (1), pp. 16-23.
A moral profession.
Terry, L. (2017). A moral profession. Nursing Ethics.
A moral profession: Nurse educators’ selected narratives of care and compassion
Newham, R, Terry, LM, Atherley, S, Hahessy, S, Babenko-Mould, Y, Evans, M, Ferguson, K, Carr, G and Cedar, SH (2017). A moral profession: Nurse educators’ selected narratives of care and compassion. Nursing Ethics. 26 (1), pp. 105-115.
An adaptable Discourse Analysis instrument and method to explore Caring and Compassion
Terry, LM and Newham, R (2017). An adaptable Discourse Analysis instrument and method to explore Caring and Compassion. Nurse Researcher. 24 (3), pp. 8-12.
An adaptable Discourse Analysis instrument and method to explore Caring and Compassion
Terry, LM and Newham, R (2017). An adaptable Discourse Analysis instrument and method to explore Caring and Compassion. Nurse Researcher. 24 (2), pp. 8-12.
A qualitative study exploring senior nurses’ understanding of compassionate leadership in community healthcare
Ali, S and Terry, LM (2017). A qualitative study exploring senior nurses’ understanding of compassionate leadership in community healthcare. British Journal of Community Nursing. 22 (2).
Exploring senior nurses' understanding of compassionate leadership in the community
Ali, S and Terry, LM (2017). Exploring senior nurses' understanding of compassionate leadership in the community. British Journal of Community Nursing. 22 (2), pp. 77-87.
Should nurses be role models for healthy lifestyles? Results from a modified Delphi study.
Kelly, M, Wills, JD, Jester, R and Speller, V (2017). Should nurses be role models for healthy lifestyles? Results from a modified Delphi study. Journal of Advanced Nursing. 73 (3), pp. 665-678.
A longitudinal, mixed methods investigation of newly qualified nurses’ workplace stressors and stress experiences during transition
Halpin, Y, Terry, LM and Curzio, J (2017). A longitudinal, mixed methods investigation of newly qualified nurses’ workplace stressors and stress experiences during transition. Journal of Advanced Nursing. 73 (11), pp. 2577-2586.
Understanding and applying the precautionary principle
Terry, LM (2017). Understanding and applying the precautionary principle. Family Law. 47 (11), pp. 1210-1215.
A research-based mantra for compassionate caring
Terry, LM, Newham, R, Hahessy, S, Atherley, S, Babenko-Mould, Y, Evans, M, Ferguson, K, Carr, G and Cedar, SH (2017). A research-based mantra for compassionate caring. Nurse Education Today. 58, pp. 1-11.
Understanding and meeting your legal responsibilities as a nurse
Terry, LM, Carr, G and Halpin, Y (2017). Understanding and meeting your legal responsibilities as a nurse. Nursing Standard.
Partner Selection for People with Intellectual Disabilities.
Bates, C, Terry, LM and Popple, K (2016). Partner Selection for People with Intellectual Disabilities. Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities. 30 (4), pp. 602-611.
Expert nurses' perceptions of the relevance of Carper's patterns of knowing to junior nurses.
Terry, LM, Carr, G and Curzio, J (2016). Expert nurses' perceptions of the relevance of Carper's patterns of knowing to junior nurses. Advances in Nursing Science. 40 (1), pp. 85-102.
The Importance of Romantic Love to People with Learning Disabilities
Bates, C, Terry, LM and Popple, K (2016). The Importance of Romantic Love to People with Learning Disabilities. British Journal of Learning Disabilities. 45 (1), pp. 64-72.