Ectogenesis and the case against the right to the death of the foetus

Journal article


Rodger, D and Blackshaw, BP (2018). Ectogenesis and the case against the right to the death of the foetus. Bioethics.
AuthorsRodger, D and Blackshaw, BP
Abstract

Ectogenesis, or the use of artificial wombs to allow a foetus to develop, will likely become a reality within a few decades, and could significantly affect the abortion debate. We first examine the implications for Judith Jarvis Thomson’s violinist analogy, which argues for a woman’s right to withdraw life support from the foetus and so terminate her pregnancy, even if the foetus is granted full moral status. We show that on Thomson’s reasoning, there is no right to the death of the foetus, and abortion is not permissible if ectogenesis is available, provided it is safe and inexpensive. This raises the question of whether there are persuasive reasons for the right to the death of the foetus that could be exercised in the context of ectogenesis. Eric Mathison and Jeremy Davis have examined several arguments for this right, doubting that it exists, while Joona Räsänen has recently criticized their reasoning. We respond to Räsänen’s analysis, concluding that his arguments are unsuccessful, and that there is no right to the death of the foetus in these circumstances.

KeywordsEctogenesis; Foetus; Moral Status; Pregnancy; 2201 Applied Ethics; 2203 Philosophy; Applied Ethics
Year2018
JournalBioethics
PublisherWiley
ISSN0269-9702
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1111/bioe.12529
Publication dates
Print20 Oct 2018
Publication process dates
Deposited16 Aug 2018
Accepted14 Aug 2018
Accepted author manuscript
License
CC BY 4.0
Permalink -

https://openresearch.lsbu.ac.uk/item/868zw

Accepted author manuscript

  • 27
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 6
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Related outputs

Why a right to life rules out infanticide: A final reply to Räsänen
Rodger, D and Blackshaw, B (2019). Why a right to life rules out infanticide: A final reply to Räsänen. Bioethics.
Surgical fires: still a burning issue in England and Wales
Rodger, D (2019). Surgical fires: still a burning issue in England and Wales. Journal of Perioperative Practice.
Using animal-derived constituents in anaesthesia and surgery: the case for disclosing to patients
Rodger, D and Blackshaw, B (2019). Using animal-derived constituents in anaesthesia and surgery: the case for disclosing to patients. BMC Medical Ethics. 20 (14).
Meeting the Epicurean Challenge: A Reply to Christensen
Rodger, D and Blackshaw, B (2019). Meeting the Epicurean Challenge: A Reply to Christensen. Journal of Medical Ethics.
The impact of stigma on the care of postpartum women with severe mental illness
Rodger, D (2019). The impact of stigma on the care of postpartum women with severe mental illness. Evidence-Based Nursing.
The aftermath of a perioperative death: who cares for the clinician?
Rodger, D and Hartley, H (2018). The aftermath of a perioperative death: who cares for the clinician? Evidence-Based Nursing.
Moral distress in healthcare assistants: an overview with recommendations
Rodger, D (2018). Moral distress in healthcare assistants: an overview with recommendations. Nursing Ethics.
Book Review: Down's Syndrome Screening and Reproductive Politics: Care, choice, and disability in the prenatal clinic.
Rodger, D (2018). Book Review: Down's Syndrome Screening and Reproductive Politics: Care, choice, and disability in the prenatal clinic. The New Bioethics. 24 (1), pp. 95-97.
Beyond infanticide: How psychological accounts of persons justify harming infants
Rodger, D, Blackshaw, B and Miller, C (2018). Beyond infanticide: How psychological accounts of persons justify harming infants. The New Bioethics.
How to mitigate the effects of peri-operative death on nursing staff
Rodger, D and Atwal, A (2018). How to mitigate the effects of peri-operative death on nursing staff. Nursing Times. 114 (8), pp. 26-29.
Why arguments against infanticide remain convincing - a reply to Joona Räsänen
Rodger, D (2018). Why arguments against infanticide remain convincing - a reply to Joona Räsänen. Bioethics.
An introduction to ethical theory for healthcare assistants
Rodger, D and Blackshaw, B (2017). An introduction to ethical theory for healthcare assistants. British Journal of Healthcare Assistants. 11 (11), pp. 556-561.
Extravasation injury leading to acute compartment syndrome in a child: the vital role of pulse oximetry in early detection and management
Rodger, D (2018). Extravasation injury leading to acute compartment syndrome in a child: the vital role of pulse oximetry in early detection and management. Journal of Perioperative Practice. 28 (4), pp. 95-98.
From healthcare assistant to student operating department practitioner—are you ready for the ODP challenge?
Rodger, D and Mahoney, C (2017). From healthcare assistant to student operating department practitioner—are you ready for the ODP challenge? British Journal of Healthcare Assistants. 11 (5), pp. 248-251.