Meeting the Epicurean Challenge: A Reply to Christensen

Journal article


Rodger, D and Blackshaw, B (2019). Meeting the Epicurean Challenge: A Reply to Christensen. Journal of Medical Ethics.
AuthorsRodger, D and Blackshaw, B
Abstract

In ‘Abortion and deprivation: a reply to Marquis’, Anna Christensen contends that Don Marquis’ influential ‘future like ours’ argument for the immorality of abortion faces a significant challenge from the Epicurean claim that human beings cannot be harmed by their death. If deprivation requires a subject, then abortion cannot deprive a fetus of a future of value, as no individual exists to be deprived once death has occurred. However, the Epicurean account also implies that the wrongness of murder is also not grounded in the badness of death, which is strongly counterintuitive. There is an alternative: we can save our intuitions by adopting a more moderate Epicurean account such as that proposed by David Hershenov, who grounds the wrongness of killing in the prevention of the benefit of further good life rather than in the badness of death. Hershenov’s account, however, is equally applicable to Marquis’ argument: abortion similarly prevents a fetus from enjoying the benefit of a future like ours. Consequently, we conclude that Christensen’s criticism of Marquis’ argument fails to undermine his reasoning.

KeywordsDeath; Epicureanism
Year2019
JournalJournal of Medical Ethics
PublisherBMJ Publishing Group
ISSN1473-4257
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.1136/medethics-2018-105267
Publication dates
Print16 Feb 2019
Publication process dates
Deposited01 Feb 2019
Accepted31 Jan 2019
Accepted author manuscript
License
CC BY-NC 4.0
Permalink -

https://openresearch.lsbu.ac.uk/item/86798

  • 9
    total views
  • 15
    total downloads
  • 3
    views this month
  • 6
    downloads this month

Related outputs

Why a right to life rules out infanticide: A final reply to Räsänen
Rodger, D and Blackshaw, B (2019). Why a right to life rules out infanticide: A final reply to Räsänen. Bioethics.
Surgical fires: still a burning issue in England and Wales
Rodger, D (2019). Surgical fires: still a burning issue in England and Wales. Journal of Perioperative Practice.
Using animal-derived constituents in anaesthesia and surgery: the case for disclosing to patients
Rodger, D and Blackshaw, B (2019). Using animal-derived constituents in anaesthesia and surgery: the case for disclosing to patients. BMC Medical Ethics. 20 (14).
The impact of stigma on the care of postpartum women with severe mental illness
Rodger, D (2019). The impact of stigma on the care of postpartum women with severe mental illness. Evidence-Based Nursing.
The aftermath of a perioperative death: who cares for the clinician?
Rodger, D and Hartley, H (2018). The aftermath of a perioperative death: who cares for the clinician? Evidence-Based Nursing.
Ectogenesis and the case against the right to the death of the foetus
Rodger, D and Blackshaw, BP (2018). Ectogenesis and the case against the right to the death of the foetus. Bioethics.
Moral distress in healthcare assistants: an overview with recommendations
Rodger, D (2018). Moral distress in healthcare assistants: an overview with recommendations. Nursing Ethics.
Book Review: Down's Syndrome Screening and Reproductive Politics: Care, choice, and disability in the prenatal clinic.
Rodger, D (2018). Book Review: Down's Syndrome Screening and Reproductive Politics: Care, choice, and disability in the prenatal clinic. The New Bioethics. 24 (1), pp. 95-97.
Beyond infanticide: How psychological accounts of persons justify harming infants
Rodger, D, Blackshaw, B and Miller, C (2018). Beyond infanticide: How psychological accounts of persons justify harming infants. The New Bioethics.
How to mitigate the effects of peri-operative death on nursing staff
Rodger, D and Atwal, A (2018). How to mitigate the effects of peri-operative death on nursing staff. Nursing Times. 114 (8), pp. 26-29.
Why arguments against infanticide remain convincing - a reply to Joona Räsänen
Rodger, D (2018). Why arguments against infanticide remain convincing - a reply to Joona Räsänen. Bioethics.
An introduction to ethical theory for healthcare assistants
Rodger, D and Blackshaw, B (2017). An introduction to ethical theory for healthcare assistants. British Journal of Healthcare Assistants. 11 (11), pp. 556-561.
Extravasation injury leading to acute compartment syndrome in a child: the vital role of pulse oximetry in early detection and management
Rodger, D (2018). Extravasation injury leading to acute compartment syndrome in a child: the vital role of pulse oximetry in early detection and management. Journal of Perioperative Practice. 28 (4), pp. 95-98.
From healthcare assistant to student operating department practitioner—are you ready for the ODP challenge?
Rodger, D and Mahoney, C (2017). From healthcare assistant to student operating department practitioner—are you ready for the ODP challenge? British Journal of Healthcare Assistants. 11 (5), pp. 248-251.