Using chronic kidney disease trigger tools for safety and learning: a qualitative evaluation in East London primary care

Journal article


Thomas, N, Hull, S and Rajabzadeh, V (2019). Using chronic kidney disease trigger tools for safety and learning: a qualitative evaluation in East London primary care. British Journal of General Practice. 69 (687), pp. e715 - e723.
AuthorsThomas, N, Hull, S and Rajabzadeh, V
Abstract

Background
An innovative programme to improve identification and management of chronic kidney disease (CKD) in primary care was implemented across three clinical commissioning groups (CCGs) in 2016. This included a falling estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) trigger tool built from data within the electronic health record (EHR). This patient safety tool notifies GP practices when falling eGFR values are identified. By alerting clinicians to patients with possible CKD progression the tool invites clinical review, the option for specialist advice, and written reflection on management.

Aim
To identify practitioner perceptions of trigger tool use and value from interview data, and compare these with the written reflections on clinical management recorded within the tools.

Method
Eight semi-structured interviews with 6 GPs, 1 pharmacist and 1 practice manager were recorded and transcribed. Thematic analysis of the interview transcripts was undertaken using framework analysis. The free-text reflective comments recorded in the trigger tools of 1,921 cases were organised by referral category ‘yes’ and ‘no’, with each category stratified by age into ‘younger’ and ‘older’ cases. Subsequently the themes arising from the interviews were compared with the descriptive analysis of the reflective comments.

Findings
Three themes emerged from interviews: Getting started, Patient safety and Practitioner and Practice learning. Well organised practices found the tool was readily embedded into workflow and expressed greater motivation for using it. The trigger tool was seen to contribute to patient safety, and as a tool for learning about CKD management, both individually and as a practice. Reflective comments from 1,921 trigger tools were examined, these supported the theme of patient safety from the interviews. However the free text data, stratified by age, challenged the expectation that younger cases would have higher referral rates, driven by a higher level of risk for CKD progression.
Conclusion
Building electronic trigger tools from the EHR can identify patients with a falling eGFR prompting review of the eGFR trajectory and management plan. Interview and reflective data illustrated that practice use of the trigger tool supported the patient safety agenda and in addition encouraged team and individual learning about CKD management.

Keywordschronic kidney diseases; patient safety; primary care; tool use behaviour; trigger tools
Year2019
JournalBritish Journal of General Practice
Journal citation69 (687), pp. e715 - e723
PublisherRoyal College of General Practitioners
ISSN0960-1643
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)doi:10.3399/bjgp19X705497
Publication dates
PrintOct 2019
Publication process dates
Deposited21 May 2019
Accepted21 May 2019
Accepted author manuscript
License
CC BY 4.0
File Access Level
Open
Permalink -

https://openresearch.lsbu.ac.uk/item/8668q

Restricted files

Accepted author manuscript

  • 35
    total views
  • 1
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 1
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

International perspectives on Patient Involvement in Clinical Trials in Nephrology
Banerjee, D, Lowe-Jones, R, Damster, S, Thomas, N, Scholes-Robertson, N, Tong, A and Levin, A (2020). International perspectives on Patient Involvement in Clinical Trials in Nephrology. Kidney International.
Innovative education for people with chronic kidney disease: an evaluation study
Rainey, H, Hussain, S and Thomas, N (2020). Innovative education for people with chronic kidney disease: an evaluation study. Journal of Renal Care.
Do virtual renal clinics improve access to kidney care? A preliminary impact evaluation of a virtual clinic in east London.
Hull, S., Rajabzadeh, V., Thomas, N., Hoong, S., Dreyer, G., Rainey, H. and Ashman, N. (2020). Do virtual renal clinics improve access to kidney care? A preliminary impact evaluation of a virtual clinic in east London. BMC Nephrology. 21 (10).
Involvement of young people in a qualitative study that seeks to explore experiences of renal replacement therapy choice selection
Ofori-Ansah, S., Thomas, N., Jones, J., Evans, M. and Bullen, C Involvement of young people in a qualitative study that seeks to explore experiences of renal replacement therapy choice selection. UK Kidney Week Conference. Brighton 03 - 05 Jun 2019
Young adults' experiences of dialysis or kidney transplant decision-making
Ofori-Ansah, S., Thomas, N., Jones, J. and Evans, M. (2019). Young adults' experiences of dialysis or kidney transplant decision-making. PGR Summer School Conference. London South Bank University 01 - 04 Jul 2019
Involvement of young people in a qualitative study that seeks to explore experiences of renal replacement therapy choice selection
Ofori-Ansah, S., Thomas, N., Jones, J. and Evans, M. (2019). Involvement of young people in a qualitative study that seeks to explore experiences of renal replacement therapy choice selection . PGR Summer School Conference. London South Bank University 01 - 04 Jul 2019 London South Bank University.
In review: Chronic kidney disease
Thomas, N. (2019). In review: Chronic kidney disease. Nursing in Practice.
Improving coding and primary care management for people with Chronic Kidney Disease: an observational controlled study in east London.
Hull, S, Rajabzadeh, V, Thomas, N, Hoong, S, Dreyer, G, Rainey, H and Ashman, N (2019). Improving coding and primary care management for people with Chronic Kidney Disease: an observational controlled study in east London. British Journal of General Practice.
Nurse practitioner consultations in primary health care: An observational interaction analysis of social interactions and consultation outcomes - ERRATUM
Barratt, J and Thomas, N (2018). Nurse practitioner consultations in primary health care: An observational interaction analysis of social interactions and consultation outcomes - ERRATUM. Primary Health Care Research and Development. 20.
Classification of chronic kidney disease ten years on: what have we learnt and what do we need to do now?
Thomas, NM (2018). Classification of chronic kidney disease ten years on: what have we learnt and what do we need to do now? Family Practice. 35 (4), pp. 349-351.
Innovating and evaluating education for people with kidney disease
Thomas, NM and Rainey, H (2018). Innovating and evaluating education for people with kidney disease. Journal of Kidney Care. 3 (2), pp. 114-119.
Personal information documents for people with dementia: healthcare staff’s perceptions and experiences
Baillie, LJ and Thomas, NM (2018). Personal information documents for people with dementia: healthcare staff’s perceptions and experiences. Dementia.
Nurse practitioner consultations in primary health care: patient, carer, and nurse practitioner qualitative interpretations of communication processes
Barratt, J and Thomas, NM (2018). Nurse practitioner consultations in primary health care: patient, carer, and nurse practitioner qualitative interpretations of communication processes. Primary Health Care Research and Development. 20 (e37).
Nurse practitioner consultations in primary health care: an observational interaction analysis of social interactions and consultation outcomes
Barratt, J and Thomas, NM (2018). Nurse practitioner consultations in primary health care: an observational interaction analysis of social interactions and consultation outcomes. Primary Health Care Research and Development. 20 (e37).
Nurse practitioner consultations in primary health care: a case study-based survey of patients’ pre-consultation expectations, and post-consultation satisfaction and enablement
Barratt, J and Thomas, NM (2018). Nurse practitioner consultations in primary health care: a case study-based survey of patients’ pre-consultation expectations, and post-consultation satisfaction and enablement. Primary Health Care Research and Development. 20.
Making our research relevant and visible to patients and the public
Thomas, N (2018). Making our research relevant and visible to patients and the public. Journal of Renal Care. 44 (3), pp. 127-127.
Changing from 12 hour to 8 hour day shifts: a qualitative exploration of effects on organising nursing care and staffing
Baillie, LJ and Thomas, NM (2018). Changing from 12 hour to 8 hour day shifts: a qualitative exploration of effects on organising nursing care and staffing. Journal of Clinical Nursing. 28 (1-2), pp. 148-158.
Service User Involvement in Healthcare Improvement
Thomas, NM (2017). Service User Involvement in Healthcare Improvement. in: Baillie, L and Maxwell, E (ed.) Improving Healthcare A Handbook for Practitioners CRC Press.
The service user and carer perspective
Thomas, NM, Baillie, LJ and Maxwell, E (2016). The service user and carer perspective. in: Tranvag, O, Synnes, O and McSherry, W (ed.) Stories of Dignity Within Healthcare Research, Narratives and Theories M&K Publishing. pp. 97-110
The Cornish Experience Of The ASSIST-CKD Project
Barton, A.L., Mallard, A.S., Patterson, A., Thomas, NM, Dickinson, S. and Gallagher, H. (2017). The Cornish Experience Of The ASSIST-CKD Project. Annals of Clinical Biochemistry. 55 (1).
A programme to spread eGFR graph surveillance for the early identification, support and treatment of people with progressive chronic kidney disease (ASSIST-CKD): protocol for the stepped wedge implementation and evaluation of an intervention to reduce late presentation for renal replacement therapy
Thomas, NM, Gallagher, H, Methven, S, Casula, A, Tomson, C and Caskey, F (2017). A programme to spread eGFR graph surveillance for the early identification, support and treatment of people with progressive chronic kidney disease (ASSIST-CKD): protocol for the stepped wedge implementation and evaluation of an intervention to reduce late presentation for renal replacement therapy. BMC Nephrology. 18, p. 131.
Introducing a device to assist in the application of anti-embolism stockings
Thomas, NM and Bennett, N (2017). Introducing a device to assist in the application of anti-embolism stockings. British Journal of Nursing. 26 (9).
How does the length of day shift affect patient care on older people's wards? A mixed method study
Baillie, LJ and Thomas, NM (2017). How does the length of day shift affect patient care on older people's wards? A mixed method study. International Journal of Nursing Studies. 75, pp. 154-162.
New ways of working; delivering better care for people with long-term conditions
Tzortziou Brown, V, Patel, I, Thomas, NM, Tomlinson, J, Roberts, R, Rayner, H, Ashman, N and Hull, S (2017). New ways of working; delivering better care for people with long-term conditions. London Journal of Primary Care.
Partnership with patients and their families.
Thomas, NM (2017). Partnership with patients and their families. Journal of Renal Care. 43 (3), p. 131.
The challenge of nutritional management in people with kidney disease.
Langley-Evans, S and Thomas, NM (2017). The challenge of nutritional management in people with kidney disease. Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics. 30 (6), pp. 679-680.
The challenge of nutritional management in people with kidney disease
Langley-Evans, S and Thomas, NM (2017). The challenge of nutritional management in people with kidney disease. Journal of Renal Care. 43 (4), pp. 195-196.
Structured nursing educational programs improve quality of life outcomes in patients with Cushing's syndrome.
Llahana, S and Thomas, NM (2016). Structured nursing educational programs improve quality of life outcomes in patients with Cushing's syndrome. Endocrine. 53 (1), pp. 1-3.
What drives quality improvement in chronic kidney disease (CKD) in primary care: process evaluation of the Quality Improvement in Chronic Kidney Disease (QICKD) trial.
Nihat, A, de Lusignan, S, Thomas, NM, Tahir, MA and Gallagher, H (2016). What drives quality improvement in chronic kidney disease (CKD) in primary care: process evaluation of the Quality Improvement in Chronic Kidney Disease (QICKD) trial. BMJ Open. 6 (4).
Educating a health service workforce about dementia: a qualitative study
Baillie, LJ, Sills, E and Thomas, NM (2016). Educating a health service workforce about dementia: a qualitative study. Quality in Ageing and Older Adults. 17 (2), pp. 119 -130.
Editorial
Thomas, NM (2016). Editorial. Journal of Renal Care. 42 (3), pp. 135-136.
The Experience of Older People in the Shared Decision-Making Process in Advanced Kidney Care
Thomas, NM (2016). The Experience of Older People in the Shared Decision-Making Process in Advanced Kidney Care. BioMed Research International. 2016.