Utopias: Future, Present and Concrete in Alasdair MacIntyre and C.L.R. James

Journal article


Blackledge, P (2018). Utopias: Future, Present and Concrete in Alasdair MacIntyre and C.L.R. James. International Critical Thought.
AuthorsBlackledge, P
Abstract

Alasdair MacIntyre’s Ethics in the Conflict of Modernity (2016) caps a long engagement with Marx and Marxism. In this most recent engagement, MacIntyre provides a narrative of the life of C. L. R. James, the Trinidadian writer, Marxist, and political activist. For MacIntyre, James fits into his standard interpretation of Marxisms that have failed. This is a doubly interesting point because James influenced MacIntyre’s early Marxism and MacIntyre’s mature critique of Marxism can be understood against the background of his failure to realise a broadly Jamesian political project in the 1960s. Moreover, MacIntyre’s mature concept of a “utopianism of the present” can, in part, be understood as an attempt to overcome the abstract utopian limitations of the politics he embraced in his youth. I argue that MacIntyre was right to reject the interpretation of Marxism he held in the mid-1960s, but that his general criticism of Marxism is less successful because Marxism, at its strongest, can be understood as a form of a utopianism of the present, or, as Ernst Bloch termed it, a concrete utopia. The underlying flaw with the version of Marxism that MacIntyre embraced in the 1960s is not to be found in its abstractly utopian character but rather in its one-sided conception of the relationship between working-class self-activity and socialist consciousness. This is a problem, though inverted, that continues to haunt MacIntyre’s interpretation of Marxism.

Year2018
JournalInternational Critical Thought
PublisherRoutledge
Publication process dates
Deposited21 Jul 2018
Accepted07 Jul 2018
Accepted author manuscript
License
CC BY 4.0
Permalink -

https://openresearch.lsbu.ac.uk/item/86q37

  • 22
    total views
  • 1
    total downloads
  • 4
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Related outputs

The split in the international and the origins of war
Blackledge, P (2013). The split in the international and the origins of war. in: Brincat, S (ed.) Communism in the 21st Century Santa Barbara Praeger.
Sport: Capitalism at Play
Blackledge, P (2014). Sport: Capitalism at Play. Socialist Review.
Frederick Engels, Social Reproduction, and the Problem of a Unitary Theory of Women’s Oppression in advance
Blackledge, P (2018). Frederick Engels, Social Reproduction, and the Problem of a Unitary Theory of Women’s Oppression in advance. Social Theory and Practice. 44 (3), pp. 297-321.
Politics and Ethics
Blackledge, P (2014). Politics and Ethics. Studies in Marxism. 14.
Historical Materialism
Blackledge, P (2018). Historical Materialism. in: Vidal, M (ed.) Oxford Handbook on Karl Marx Oxford Oxford University Press.
The New Left: Beyond Stalinism and Social Democracy?
Blackledge, P (2014). The New Left: Beyond Stalinism and Social Democracy? in: Smtih, E (ed.) Against the grain: The British far left from 1956 Manchester Manchester University Press.
Once More on Left Refromism
Blackledge, P (2014). Once More on Left Refromism. International Socialism.
G.A. Cohen and the Limits of Analytical Marxism
Blackledge, P (2015). G.A. Cohen and the Limits of Analytical Marxism. in: Thompson, M (ed.) Constructing Marxist Ethics Leiden Brill.
The Dialectics of Work and Leisure in Marx, Lukács and Lefebvre
Blackledge, P (2017). The Dialectics of Work and Leisure in Marx, Lukács and Lefebvre. in: Spracklen, K (ed.) The Palgrave Handbook of Leisure Theory London Palgrave.
War and Revolution: Friedrich Engels as a Military and Political Thinker
Blackledge, P (2019). War and Revolution: Friedrich Engels as a Military and Political Thinker. War and Society. 38 (2), pp. 81-97.
Hegemony and Intervention: Alan Shandro's Lenin
Blackledge, P (2018). Hegemony and Intervention: Alan Shandro's Lenin. Science and Society: a journal of marxist thought and analysis. 82 (1), pp. 481-501.
Lenin: Soviet Democracy in 1917
Blackledge, P (2018). Lenin: Soviet Democracy in 1917. in: Márquez, X (ed.) Democratic Moments: Reading Democratic Texts Bloomsbury Academic.
On Strategy and Tactics Marxism and Electoral Politics
Blackledge, P (2017). On Strategy and Tactics Marxism and Electoral Politics. Historical Materialism.
Practical Materialism: Engels’s Anti-Dühring as Marxist Philosophy
Blackledge, P (2017). Practical Materialism: Engels’s Anti-Dühring as Marxist Philosophy. Critique: Journal of Socialist Theory.